Skip to content
Esports Coverage

Embark Studios removed AI commentator reel after caster backlash

Embark also canceled the AMER and EMEA recaps in the same AI format and said it is rethinking all three regional videos.

https://quarterstack.online/esports/embark-studios-ai-commentator-reel-caster-backlash/

Share

Key facts

  • Embark Studios replaced human esports casters with the game's fictional AI commentators, Scotty and June, in a highlight reel recapping The Finals Grand Major's APAC Closed Qualifiers.
  • Commentator Proto / Kai posted on Twitter/X on November 16, 2026 that he, @TheeHyperactive, and @bluepanda_casts were replaced by two AI casters that quote them after four qualifier cycles.
  • Caster Bluepanda said he was told for nearly seven years that his work was valued, then was ghosted or told his services were no longer needed.
  • Fighting game commentator Damascus said AI casters trained on actual casters is devious and that esports is moving toward an absolute slop era.

Embark Studios replaced human esports casters with the game’s fictional AI commentators, Scotty and June, in a highlight reel recapping The Finals Grand Major’s APAC Closed Qualifiers on Nov. 18, 2026, then removed the video after casters criticized the move.

Commentator Proto / Kai posted on Twitter/X on November 16, 2026 that he, @TheeHyperactive, and @bluepanda_casts were replaced by two AI casters that quote them after four qualifier cycles. Proto said he understands Scotty and June are part of the game but called the replacement yikes-inducing. He thanked @reachthefinals in the post.

Caster Bluepanda said he was told for nearly seven years that his work was valued, then was ghosted or told his services were no longer needed. Fighting game commentator Damascus said AI casters trained on actual casters are devious and that esports is moving toward an absolute slop era.

Embark said it chose Scotty and June to introduce The Grand Major due to player familiarity but decided it was not the right direction given the original commentators’ work. The company said its team selected broadcast clips, wrote an original script, and produced new commentary for Scotty and June, and it said it was grateful to its talent for their candid feedback and acknowledged the decision was wrong, but leaving out the casters was not the right call. Oscar Lundberg, Competitive Experience and Community at Embark Studios and The Finals, said leaving out the casters and talent was a mistake and that the video will not return in that form. Lundberg said, “Yesterday we released a recap of the APAC Closed Qualifier that left out the casters and talent who made that event.”

Embark took the video down and said the AMER and EMEA recaps in the same format will no longer be released. The company said the AMER and EMEA recaps planned in the same AI format will not go out as planned and that it is rethinking all three regional recaps.

Scotty and June are fictional commentators in The Finals voiced by paid human actors, but their lines are generated by text-to-speech and an AI model trained on those voices. The Finals’ Dynamic Commentary feature, announced in October, lets Scotty and June refer to players by screen names and call out specific match moments based on in-game context.

Arc Raiders, another Embark Studios game, uses AI for voice lines calling out items and locations. Design director Virgil Watkins said in Nov. 2025 that contracted voice actors agreed to AI use in their contracts. Watkins said the AI allows the ping system to say every item name, every location name, and compass directions without needing someone to come in every time the game creates a new item.

Proto said Embark’s organizers took parts of what casters said from the original VOD but did not feed the VOD itself into the AI, causing the AI to repeat caster lines. Proto said Embark looked through the VOD, found clips and moments, wrote a script, and handed it to a scriptwriter before line creation.

He said all esports talent, including casters, producers, broadcasters, camera operators, and production assistants, should create a union to protect against AI replacing human workers. Proto also called for a global talent hiatus with contracts banning voice use in generative AI. He mentioned auto-AI observe features in Counter-Strike and The Finals as examples of production jobs also at risk from automation.

Proto warned the debacle could be a canary in the coal mine for esports talent, potentially leading circuits to stop paying human talent in favor of cheaper AI. He described the handling of The Finals esports as consistently poor and said the talent announcement for the major left everybody unhappy.

Bluepanda told IGN that Embark saw no issue until overwhelming global backlash, then answered with a dismissive “Whoopsie” attitude, and said he is done with The Finals and esports, especially in OCE.

Proto commented all four competitive cycles and the open and closed qualifiers for The Finals but was not chosen to commentate The Grand Major. Proto called for Embark to widen the major tournament talent pool, streamline next year’s competitive events, and support local communities to keep The Finals scene alive.

IGN states that most fans see using AI for NPCs and player character dialogue as one thing, but replacing real-life commentators who poured hours into analysis as another matter entirely.

The Finals Grand Major 2026 is scheduled for November 27-29 at DreamHack Stockholm and is organized by Embark Studios with the eESL FaceIT Group. 16 teams will compete at The Grand Major 2026 for a $150,000 prize pool, with $50,000 going to the champions. Three teams earned direct invitations and 13 advance through Closed Qualifiers.

Five Fears from EMEA, Luminon Gaming from AMERICAS, and KingZero from APAC received direct invitations to The Grand Major 2026 after finishing first in regional Online Series standings, with $50,000 paid out over four competitive cycles. Five Fears secured its invitation early with a cycle to spare, Luminon Gaming took first place in the final cycle after climbing every cycle, and KingZero reclaimed the APAC lead in the final stretch.

During the first two days at DreamHack Stockholm, the Promotion format cuts the field from 16 teams to five, using four-team Cashout matches followed by head-to-head Final Rounds. Sunday introduces The Throne format in which one team holds the leading position, four challengers battle through Cashout to face them in a best-of-three Final Round, and the first team to three crowns becomes world champion.

Was this helpful?

Join the discussion

Please read our Comment Policy before commenting. First-time comments are held for moderation. By posting a comment you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, which explain how your name, email address and comment are used.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *