Skip to content
Studio, Publisher & Industry Business

Nicalis deploys Binding of Isaac Repentance+ patch after AI music backlash

Edmund McMillen said on X he had no idea how generated music reached the daily run, and Nicalis deployed the PC patch hours later.

https://quarterstack.online/industry-business/binding-isaac-repentance-ai-music-patch/

Share

Key facts

  • Nicalis removed undisclosed AI-generated music from The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ after undisclosed tracks triggered a Steam review-bombing campaign and prompted a public response from creator Edmund McMillen.
  • McMillen posted on X that he woke up to a shit show, had no idea the daily run featured generated music, was looking into how it happened, and was getting it removed.
  • The undisclosed AI music was tied exclusively to a Grand Theft Auto-themed daily run unlocked with seed V1CE BSMT, created to coincide with GTA 6, and made up of seven full songs plus intros and outros.
  • McMillen told Eurogamer the GTA 6 release idea was Nicalis', saying the team was done and had to release that month and calling the stunt a fun experiment.

Nicalis deployed a critical-fixes build for The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ at 10.11pm GMT on November 21, 2026, removing undisclosed AI-generated music after undisclosed tracks triggered a Steam review-bombing campaign and prompted a public response from creator Edmund McMillen.

The update went live on PC and had already been submitted to Microsoft, Nintendo, and Sony, with console timing unspecified. Nicalis also pledged to make console players eligible for the same discount as PC players.

Series creator Edmund McMillen said on November 21, 2026, that he had no idea how AI-generated music found its way into the launch build of Repentance+’s new update. He posted on X that he woke up to a shit show and was looking into how it happened and getting it removed, writing, “obviously I had no idea it featured generated music in the daily run”.

The undisclosed music was tied to a Grand Theft Auto-themed daily run unlocked with seed V1CE BSMT and made to coincide with GTA 6. The run contained seven full songs plus derivative intros and outros, 14 files in total.

Several files carried metadata reading made with Suno, an AI-based music generation tool, and one track showed a creation date of October 30, 2026, less than three weeks before the November 19, 2026, launch.

Reddit user ShweetsStuff reported the questionable music one day after the November 19, 2026 launch, backing the claim with tracks that mention Suno in their metadata and include links to Suno pages. Negative reviews poured in following the discovery. Certain files had their Suno comment metadata removed after later editing or exporting, though remaining files still served as proof.

The Steam listing displayed no AI-generated content disclosure even though Valve requires developers to describe AI-generated content shipped with games, explicitly including sound.

Review figures differ by outlet. IGN reported that just 8% of Repentance+’s recent Steam reviews were positive. Kotaku said the expansion’s Steam user rating sat at 9% positive amid the review-bomb, with reviews blaming AI music and a lack of bug fixes. Power Up Gaming reported that just 8% of 1,205 reviews submitted over the past 30 days were positive at the time of writing, and the game’s recent Steam reviews stayed in the Overwhelmingly Negative user-review category following the patch.

Players also faulted the launch for crashes, broken mods, ongoing bugs and latency, and for charging console players. Repentance+ was free on Steam in November 2024 but Nicalis listed a $9.99 upgrade for existing owners on PS5, Xbox Series X|S and Switch 2, with the Switch 2 retail edition priced at $69.99. Nicalis pledged to work with console first parties to ensure everyone who purchased Repentance is eligible for the discount.

Close-up of hands holding a black Xbox controller with colorful ABXY buttons during gameplay.
A player grips an Xbox controller while playing a video game. Photo by Olichel on Pixabay

A large share of player criticism was aimed at publisher and co-developer Nicalis. One player review said the long-delayed update offered only a few bug fixes and nothing else.

Nicalis had not provided an explanation for how or why the AI-generated music was included, had not taken responsibility for its use, and had not added a Steam disclosure. The team said it was working on the game and would continue to address new and old bugs. McMillen asked players to send issue and bug reports to the developers.

The emergency patch also fixed a Larynx + Car Battery bug and mod-compatibility problems. The update continued work on improving netcode and stability.

Nicalis and Edmund McMillen spent months preparing for the November 19, 2026, launch, which arrived on Steam the same day as Rockstar’s open-world blockbuster after a major publicity push but without a Steam AI disclosure. The update also brought Repentance+ to Nintendo Switch 2, PlayStation 5, and Xbox Series X/S.

McMillen told Eurogamer that the GTA 6 release idea was Nicalis’, saying the team was done and had to release that month and calling the stunt a fun experiment. He recounted asking whether it would be funny and going along with it because the team needed to release that month.

Repentance+ adds hundreds of changes since the original Repentance expansion launched in 2021. It includes over 700 collectible items, 34 playable characters, over 330 enemy types, more than 120 bosses and minibosses, a new item description feature, and promised cross-save and crossplay.

The launch package features four-player online co-op and built-in item descriptions, with crossplay and Steam save imports coming later. The physical Switch 2 release ships the complete game on a standard cartridge instead of a Game-Key Card and includes a reversible cover insert, manual, and PVC Isaac and Guppy strap.

Power Up Gaming frames the episode as another flashpoint in gaming’s wider AI debate, following Take-Two CEO Strauss Zelnick’s recent comments about AI and industry jobs. Hours after McMillen’s statement on November 21, 2026, Nicalis launched a patch confirming removal of generated music files.

Was this helpful?

Join the discussion

Please read our Comment Policy before commenting. First-time comments are held for moderation. By posting a comment you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, which explain how your name, email address and comment are used.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *